How do you know when a man TRULY loves you? Here's 10 signs he's passionately in love with you big time. When you're dating, he'll try to win you over. You've been on a date (or two) and you really like him. And if you still need help figuring out if a guy you like actually likes you back, take our. The only problem with dating a shy guy is you're left to wonder if he actually likes you or is just being polite. (As to whether nice guys actually.